Skip to content
Back to classes
Community debate / Classes

Should Tank Dungeon Drops Add Threat?

A WoW Forever player argues that tank-only dungeon gear could use bonus threat, but replies question whether it would help tanks choose gear—or make gearing harder.

WoW Forever News
Published 2 min read

The gear tradeoff

A Protection Warrior player says attack power contributes directly to their threat per second, which can make DPS gear tempting. They point to gimmick tank items such as Turtle Armour from Ghamoo-ra: its special appeal comes with a tradeoff between threat and survivability.[4]

Their proposed fix is to give bonus threat to items designed exclusively for tanks. The idea is to make those drops more attractive without forcing tanks to sacrifice as much threat for defensive utility; the player notes that some +threat items already exist.[4]

The concern about loot

One reply argues that defense is the tank stat and that threat already rises with damage. In their view, adding another threat bonus—especially alongside useful stats—could encourage damage dealers to claim the gear and make tank item choices harder.[3]

The discussion also reflects a different tension: one player says they know offensive gear is the correct choice, yet still enjoy unusual items. That points to the appeal of distinctive tank drops as well as their performance tradeoffs.[1]

What counts as tank gear?

A reply distinguishes Tortoise Armour, described as having only a small magic-damage reduction, from Treacherous Treads and Twilight Lord Girdle, which it says already offer strength or stamina alongside tank qualities. That distinction matters to the proposal: the argument is strongest for items whose defensive gimmick competes with stats valued for threat.[2]

TL;DR

  • The proposal is to add bonus threat to items meant exclusively for tanks, so choosing survivability gear need not mean giving up as much threat.[4]
  • A reply worries that useful extra stats could tempt damage dealers to take the items, while another player values unusual tank gear despite recognizing the appeal of offensive stats.[3][1]

Coverage is partial. This briefing reflects the sources and discussion samples collected at publication time. Follow the citations for more context.

Go to the source

  1. Blizzard Forums (US)Suggestion: dungeon tank drops should have +threat (opens in a new tab)
    Published Checked
  2. Blizzard Forums (US)Suggestion: dungeon tank drops should have +threat (opens in a new tab)
    Published Checked
  3. Blizzard Forums (US)Suggestion: dungeon tank drops should have +threat (opens in a new tab)
    Published Checked
  4. Blizzard Forums (US)Suggestion: dungeon tank drops should have +threat (opens in a new tab)
    Published Checked