Shadow Priest Feedback Splits Between Trimming and More Flavor
Players disagree over whether Shadow’s talent tree needs simpler, more efficient points or a new proc to make the spec feel more engaging.
WoW Forever NewsMake Each Point Count
One player says the goal of condensing talents is not simply to free points, but to fix inefficiencies and make each point feel worthwhile. They point to Improved Mind Blast: in their view, the fifth point was a trap, while reducing the talent to two points allows a six-second Mind Blast and fully removes the added threat at 2/2.[2]
A Call for More Flavor
A different player argues that Shadow lacks a fun, low-chance proc and suggests possible triggers such as damage-over-time ticks, non-critical Mind Blasts, or fully channeled Mind Flays. They see the request as a modest addition rather than a major redesign.[1]
That player also says Shadow’s current talent options offer little benefit in Shadowform beyond Meditation, and considers Mental Agility a mild passive. They contrast Shadow unfavorably with Mage, while praising Holy Priest additions such as Prayer of Mending and Penance; they also invoke a separate complaint that Rogues feel comparatively underserved.[1]
A third commenter agrees with the case for trimming talent-tree bloat, reinforcing the efficiency side of the discussion without weighing in on the proposed proc mechanic.[3]
Room for Iteration
The discussion is taking place during beta, and the player asking for more Shadow flavor expects tuning and reworks to continue after release. The competing feedback points to two different priorities: polishing the value of existing talents or adding a distinctive mechanic to change how Shadow feels to play.[1]
TL;DR
Coverage is partial. This briefing reflects the sources and discussion samples collected at publication time. Follow the citations for more context.
Go to the source
- Blizzard Forums (US)Feedback on Shadow Priest Design (opens in a new tab)Published Checked
- Blizzard Forums (US)Feedback on Shadow Priest Design (opens in a new tab)Published Checked
- Blizzard Forums (US)Feedback on Shadow Priest Design (opens in a new tab)Published Checked